IAC 2022 - Banner

#SpaceWatchGL Opinion: China’s Super Ambitious Plans for Super Heavy Lunar Rockets

by Jean Deville 

Earlier this week, we saw a couple of significant space industry-related events in Hong Kong, namely talks by a variety of leaders from CASC, the Chinese Academy of Engineering, and others. The events took place at the University of Hong Kong and the Hong Kong Polytechnic University, and covered topics as diverse as the Tianwen-1 Mars mission, the BeiDou satellite navigation, and perhaps most notably, lunar rockets.

Screenshot from the presentation

The rocket-related talk was from Long Lehao, Academician at the Chinese Academy of Engineering and Chief Designer of the Long March series of rockets. Long Lehao’s speeches are always followed with attention, they are an excellent way to get juicy details about upcoming LM rockets, and this had already been the case for example in a speech given at Tsinghua University in May 2018. Last week, Long Lehao spoke about China’s super-heavy launch vehicle ambitions, namely a brand new design for the Long March-9, and a rocket called the Long March-5-DY that aims to bring taikonauts to the moon.

First, let’s discuss the Long March 9, which is China’s hypothetical super-heavy rocket, and which has been in discussion in the country as early as 2010. Historically, it has been known as China’s “Saturn V” or China’s “SLS”, with the objective to put significant payload (including crew) into TLI. The Long March 9 architecture has changed many, many times over the past years, and with Long Lehao’s most recent presentation, we have yet another iteration.

The part on Long March 9 only consisted of a single slide, but a very eye-catching one. The Long March 9 configuration that was visible on the left side of the slide was the version known to the public until recently, and it’s also the one that was shown to Xi Jinping at the Great Hall of the People in February 2021 (see DFH Ep. 22). It is a 3-version configuration that Long Lehao calls the “11 edition” (meaning the 2011 edition). In this well-known configuration, you have:

  • CZ-9: the heaviest version of Long March 9, which is a 3-stage rocket with 4 strap-on boosters. It’s a massive beast, capable of putting 140t in LEO (comparable to NASA’s SLS). The core stage and the strap-on boosters used the sophisticated YF-130 kerolox closed-cycle twin nozzle engine, while the second stage used 2 YF90 hydrolox engines providing each a massive 220t of thrust. The third stage was composed of 4 new-gen YF-79 25t-thrust hydrolox engines.
    It’s notable that while this rocket architecture is quite classical, the engines are newly developed engines not used in previous Long March rockets, and providing an unprecedented amount of thrust.
  • CZ-9A: is a lighter LM-9 rocket with only 2 strap-on boosters instead of 4. The payload to LEO drops from 140t to 100t (or from 50t TLI to 35t TLI).
  • CZ-9B: is the lightest version of them all, with no strap-on boosters and a payload dropping to 50t to LEO, or 20t to TLI.

Yet in the latest iteration, dubbed the 2021 edition (“21 版”), it seems that CALT modified the design, starting almost from a clean slate. Literally, everything has changed, notably:

  • There is only a unique superheavy version of the Long March 9 now, and Long Lehao justifies this by the fact that other operational rockets will cover for the lighter versions (notably the Long March 5DY, as discussed below).
    This “new gen” superheavy Long March 9 has a payload capacity of 150t to LEO, basically similar to the previous CZ-9.
  • The rocket has no strap-on boosters, and is available in a 2-stage version for LEO, or 3-stage version for other orbits (similar to the CZ-5 and 5B)

The new version of Long March 9 surprisingly provides as much payload capacity as the heaviest version of the former Long March 9, despite the absence of strap-on boosters. The main factors that make this possible are as follows:

  • The first stage has a huge number of engines: 16 YF-135 engines, which seem to be a 360t-thrust single nozzle variant of the YF-130. This is an unprecedented architecture for China, and bears some resemblance with SpaceX’s Superheavy, the booster of Starship, which houses 30 or so Raptor engines.
  • The rocket also has a larger diameter, at 10.8 m for both the 1st and 2nd stages, as opposed to 9.5m for the previous version. The new rocket is also taller, at 108m as opposed to 103m for the old version; and finally, the Long Lehao’s presentation shows common bulkhead tanks, which help fit in more rocket propellant for a given rocket size.

Next, let’s talk about the other lunar rocket, the “921 rocket”:

This was a rocket that was first mentioned by the Chinese in 2018, and was sold to the public as a faster way of getting a crewed lunar rocket operational, and this shorter time frame was enabled by reusing components that were readily available already from current rocket programs.

This rocket, now called “LM-5DY” by Long Lehao (DY = Deng Yue 登月 → lunar rocket), consists of a 3-stage rocket, using existing engines:

  • The core stage and boosters use the YF-100K, which is the latest iteration of the YF-100 kerolox engine series used on the Long March 5 to 8.
  • For the second stage, it uses the YF-100M, which is the most recent iteration of the YF-100 series vacuum optimized engines.
  • For the upper stage, it uses the good old YF-75D, a hydrolox upper stage engine which initial versions go back to the 1980s.

According to Long Lehao’s presentation, the LM-5DY would put taikonauts to the moon in 2 separate launches. A first rocket would separately send the Next-Generation Crewed Vehicle (China’s replacement for the Shenzhou spacecraft), and a second one would launch the transfer and lander modules. Both payloads look like they would dock in lunar orbit.

Another noteworthy element from the presentation on the Long March 5DY is the smaller 2-stage variant, which does not have the upper stage and the strap-on boosters. This version would be used for crewed missions into LEO, presumably for sending the Next-Generation Crewed Vehicle into orbit. This is because the current crewed rocket, the LM-2F, is unable to put such a large spacecraft into orbit.

Also, worth noting in Long Lehao’s presentation, the objective of putting taikonauts on the moon before 2030, which is ambitious and perhaps slightly in contradiction with the ILRS roadmap revealed last week, which mentioned crewed lunar missions after 2035.

There was also some talk on reusability. In the short term, the first partially reusable Long March rocket will be the Long March 8, with a reusable first stage and 2 strap-on boosters which would perform a vertical landing as a whole (presumably on a droneship). According to Long Lehao’s presentation, this would take place by the end of 2022.

Finally, there were also some interesting points on spaceplanes: Long Lehao reaffirmed that spaceplane technology was being studied, with a 3-step approach where the initial prototype in 2025 would focus on a first stage spaceplane, and in 2030 on a second stage spaceplane; with both spaceplanes using traditional rocket propulsion (火箭动力). In 2040, things would get very ambitious as China aims to fly a fully reusable, single-stage-to-orbit, combined cycle propulsion spaceplane. Basically, the holy grail of spaceflight that no country has achieved so far, and that some have deemed technologically impossible.

Check out Dongfang Hour Episode 39 on YouTube for a visual breakdown of the Long March 5DY and Long March 9 rockets.

Jean Deville; Photo courtesy of him

Jean Deville is a graduate from ISAE, where he studied aerospace engineering and specialized in fluid dynamics. A long-time aerospace enthusiast and China watcher, Jean was previously based in Toulouse and Shenzhen, and is currently working in the aviation industry between Paris and Shanghai. He also writes on a regular basis in the China Aerospace Blog. Hobbies include hiking, astrophotography, plane spotting, as well as a soft spot for Hakka food and (some) Ningxia wines.

Check Also

Space Café Radio – Artemis I Episode II – with Elkin Norena

SpaceWatch.Global Senior Editor and SpaceCafé Italy Host Dr. Emma Gatti spoke with Elkin Norena, SLS resident manager at the NASA Kennedy Space Center, about the SLS, the rocket that will take humanity back to the moon and to Mars. Elkin discusses the Artemis 1 mission and what the agency hopes to learn from this first launch of the SLS rocket.